The
aim of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild
Fauna and Flora 1973 (CITES) is to establish worldwide controls over trade
in endangered wildlife and wildlife products by listing species in three
categories:
-
CITES
Appendix I – all species threatened with extinction which are or may
be affected by trade. Trade in these taxa is strictly regulated and
commercial trade virtually prohibited.
-
CITES
Appendix II - taxa likely to become endangered if trade is not
strictly managed. Appendix II species can be commercially traded, but
trade requires an export permit.
-
CITES
Appendix III – species which any Party to the Convention identifies
as being subject to regulation within its jurisdiction.
Australia
became a signatory to CITES in 1974 and, as required, the first official
list of endangered vertebrate animals was prepared in 1980.
One
shortcoming of CITES is that there are a number of practical problems
associated with gaining protection. The requirement that a species be
nominated by a State Party and accepted by the Conference of the Parties
has meant that the species listed are mainly those that do not have major
commercial value, since there is considerable lobbying by industry for
states not to nominate commercially exploited species (Herriman et al.
1997).
Another
problem, discussed by Green and Hendry (1999), is that there is a
widespread failure to record coral species on CITES trade permits, despite
a legal obligation to do so, due to the complexity of coral taxonomy and
the volume of coral specimens in trade. Green and Hendry (1999)
experimentally tested the accuracy of non-specialists in identifying coral
genera, using existing guides, and found that only 3 of 10 genera were
identified to more than 67% accuracy. They recommended that guides
designed specifically for this purpose, and a change in emphasis under
CITES to genera rather than species, would improve the effectiveness of
CITES in monitoring trade.
|